[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: BTW was Jimmy's performance a live one?
- Subject: Re: BTW was Jimmy's performance a live one?
- From: TangerineMan <tangerineman@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Mon, 25 Aug 2008 13:40:27 -0400
But a question came to my mind: are we absolutely sure it was live
and not pre-recorded?
My guess is it was mimed. No amps with him, no pedals at his feet.
See here:
http://style.popcrunch.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/08/leona11.jpg
A patch cord is visible in the following pic, but it doesn't seem to
lead anywhere (although it could be connected to a direct box/
wireless transmitter worn on his person, it could also just be for
show):
http://style.popcrunch.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/08/leona2.jpg
The distinctive downward-slide riff in the chorus, which Jimmy never
reproduced live until the O2 concert, was audible yesterday. Unless
I'm very much mistaken, this sound was achieved at the O2 with a
pitch-shift pedal. However, as mentioned above, no pedals were
visible on top of the bus in Beijing, so if he was playing live, how
did he activate that sound?
I haven't watched the performance since it was broadcast, but I don't
recall Jimmy making any volume or tone adjustments on the guitar
while playing, which he normally would have done, especially just
before the solo. I could be wrong. Also, he normally is much more
concentrated and "on the edge" when he plays, especially in the past
15 years or so. Absolutely no offense to the man and his skills, but
this performance seemed too relaxed from him. Apart from a few
classic pursed-lip grimaces... but those are to be expected. He's
good at miming, that's all. Any professional musician is; they do it
all the time for videos.
The rest of the band and orchestra were not to be seen anywhere, ergo
their parts were probably pre-recorded. I don't think they were
hiding inside the bus. It looks like there would have been too much
machinery inside it, to operate the clamshell doors that opened up
and then the hydraulic lifts on which LL, JP, DB et al. appeared. So
if the accompanying musicians were pre-recorded, the two featured
performers probably were as well. Although it's possible that they
were the only two who were really playing live.
Jimmy had only a monitor at his feet; this could well have been for
him to hear the pre-recorded mix and play along to it. Again, I could
be wrong; maybe he was playing live and the monitor was for him to
hear the orchestra lead-in, so he would know when to come in with the
starting riff, and then the bass, drums and vocals.
Note also that all of the performances at the Opening Ceremonies had
been lip-synched or mimed (you may recall there was that controversy
about the little girl who sang the theme song, who was not the girl
who originally performed the song--she had been deemed "not pretty
enough"). I don't see why things would have been any different for
the Closing Ceremonies. And, as I mentioned in another post
yesterday, at the 2006 Winter Olympics in Torino, even Pavarotti lip-
synched the "Nessun Dorma" aria from Turandot, because he knew he
wouldn't have been able to sing it in the cold. There is too much
riding on events of this scale to run the risk of a glitch, technical
or otherwise.
Lastly, I now suspect that Guy Pratt's blog post about playing WLL
with Jimmy and Leona referred to the fact that they had just finished
pre-recording it. It wasn't a "watch for me at the Olympics" message;
he knew he wouldn't be seen at the Closing Ceremonies, and so he felt
compelled to tell his fans (both of them :-P ) about his involvement.
I wonder if we'll ever find out who was on drums...