Re: 7-13-73 SB disc 1 bogus?

["Rudy" <zepp71@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

well, i just chkd georgia on my mind  with song of detroit and yes its the
same in between song chatter... And plants voice cracks in the same places.
the crazy thing is that the SB on song of detroit is better than georgia on
my mind. who is holding those master tapes!
i chkd disc 2 and heartbreaker is different.  though lesser quality than
disc 1.
thanks for the update vinnie
Rudy-

- ----- Original Message -----
From: "vinnie" <2gandrews@xxxxxxxxxx>
To: "FBO" <zeppelin@xxxxxxxx>
Sent: Friday, April 11, 2003 9:14 PM
Subject: 7-13-73 SB disc 1 bogus?


> Hi Everybody. I just caught this bit of info at Underground Uprising.
> Check out the second paragraph. Has anybody else noticed this from Disc
> 1??
>
> 13-Jul-73 Detroit
> Song of Detroit. SQ ***** Appeal: General
>
> Detroit July 13th. The SQ's less flat than the old Babe I'm Gonna Leave
> You release on Dynamite Studios, but new source is longer at 96'
> compared to 53' for Babe... Dazed has the first minute or so missing,
> (this and STH are the only new tracks from this show). Dancing Days is
> just as incomplete as One More Daze, although Plant's intro spiel does
> confirm it as being from this show. Packaging in standard double jewel
> case with (unremarkable) foldout pic sleeve. Worth upgrading. (Paul
> Apple Nov 2000)
>
> Underground Uprising has received the following observation regarding
> this release, so fans should be careful:-
> "A friend of mine thought that the 7/13/1973 "Song of Detroit" sounded a
> bit too much like 5/26/1973 Salt Lake City 1973 (on Watch Tower) and I
> confirmed the fact. The songs of issue is Dazed And Confused and
> Stairway To Heaven. This was the extra material that made this a more
> complete release than say the V 1/2 material. Plant's comments between
> these two tracks match. It appears that Celebration got away with this
> as I see that bootledz lists it as a more complete show, and your site
> lists it as a worthy upgrade. When you get a chance take a listen to
> both shows and if you agree with my friend and I please note the issue
> on your website so that people are aware." (Ben Bowen March 03)
>
>
>
> Vince
> my led zep page
> http://vinnieman2.tripod.com/ledzep.html